It’s no secret that patrons’ ways of exploring shows in their area and purchasing tickets are constantly evolving. It can be hard to keep up with the changing trends, new subscription expectations, and best ways to capture the attention of your patrons and potential donors. One way to rectify this issue is to take a long, hard look at your marketing efforts and consider evolving them, too. 

“Why do innovative marketing strategies matter?” you may ask. Well, great marketing strategies: 

  • Create and reinforce your theatre’s brand, which leads to stronger brand awareness and loyalty. 
  • Increase ticket sales as more patrons become interested in what you have to offer
  • Cultivate a personal relationship with your audience, leading to more tickets sold and more donations collected 

As you begin working on marketing your fall productions, it’s easy to fall back into old habits that have worked for you in the past. But times are changing – and so should your strategies. On The Stage offers a few ways to freshen up your marketing plan this year. 

Marketing Basics to Keep in Mind

Start with a Plan

When developing new marketing strategies, don’t create them in a rush or with a willy-nilly attitude. Instead, sit down—either by yourself or with your creative team—to devise a multi-pronged plan of attack.

During your planning sessions, determine the best way to use your resources and the budget you’ve allotted to achieve the greatest return. 

Make Your Marketing Goals Realistic 

We’ve all heard of S.M.A.R.T. goals – specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound. For the sake of brevity, we’ll focus on the ‘achievable’ part.

When planning your marketing strategies, it’s important to be realistic. Depending on the size of your audience or the numbers in your bank account, you may not be able to enact an all-out media blitz and go viral. Instead, study your data to see what achievable goals you can reach, whether they’re increasing engagement, adding new donors, gaining social media followers, or selling more tickets. You want to set yourself and your team up for success, not disappointment. 

Showcase Your Offerings Truthfully

Your marketing efforts should reflect your theatre’s actual offerings. The last thing you want to do is present a false narrative about what you and your team can do and then fail to deliver. 

Additionally, make sure you’re marketing each show correctly. You don’t want people buying a ticket to a show thinking it’s a 90-minute play when, in reality, it’s a two-act musical. Being deceitful about your offerings may initially attract more people to your theatre, but your relationship with the community and credibility will suffer. It’s always best to be honest!

Keep Branding Consistent 

A key element to remember when it comes to marketing is to remain consistent in your branding. This means your theatre’s logos, fonts, messaging, billboards, merchandise, and other content should be visually similar.

That’s not to say that every piece of your marketing should look exactly the same, but there should be a recognizable pattern between them. This will help tremendously with brand recognition and cultivating a more loyal patron base.

Know Your Audience

Your marketing efforts may fall flat if you aren’t sure who your audience really is. That said, consult your data on the patron demographics you’re serving. Once you’ve done so, you can tailor your marketing to the right people and create content that genuinely resonates with them. The information you should seek ranges from age and profession to gender, lifestyle choices, and general interests. 

6 Fresh Ways to Market Your Fall Production

Use a Multi-Faceted Marketing Approach

Marketing in 2024 requires much more than a singular poster or a measly e-blast. Your marketing efforts should be multi-pronged and reach as many people in as many forms as possible.

Multi-faceted marketing includes:

  • Social media content tailored to the specific platform, from short-form videos on TikTok to visually compelling images on Instagram
  • A best-in-class show site that gives patrons all the information they need to know before they visit
  • In-depth, compelling press releases and media kits for any and all media outlets 
  • Posters, billboards, other signage, and merchandise promoting your theatre 
  • Email marketing to directly reach new and existing donors 

And that’s only the beginning! Even once you have a new marketing strategy in place, there are always more ways to promote your shows. (The work is never done!)

Partner with Businesses or Influencers

Finding a partner in your marketing efforts can help you spread the word about all you offer. There are several ways to go about this, including:

  • Form Community Partnerships: Whether you link up with other creative entities in your area to spread the word or get permission to hang your posters in local businesses, forming positive working relationships with others in your area is always a great idea
  • Establish Business Sponsorships: Getting a local or national brand/company to sponsor your theatre will reap various benefits. You’ll gain a new foothold with that business’ established audience and the necessary capital to make your theatre even greater
  • Partner with Local Influencers: If you want to broaden your audience or reach younger folks, striking deals with influencers in your area is a great option. This will lead to strong social media engagement, more tickets sold, and unlock a new demographic

Optimize Your Digital Reach

In 2024, there is simply no excuse for having a weak internet presence. After all, an out-of-date website or barren Instagram account can spell disaster for your ticket sales. 

That said, it’s time to focus on establishing a strong digital footprint for your theatre. This can range from:

  • Creating or strengthening your Google Business listing
  • Understanding Search Engine Optimization so your theatre is on page one of community searches 
  • Updating your theatre’s website with all relevant information front and center
  • Utilizing an easy-to-use ticketing software to ensure the check-out process is as streamlined as possible
  • Encouraging Google reviews of your theatre to establish a positive reputation online
  • Understanding keyword searches to prioritize digital visibility truly 

Start or Improve Loyalty Programs

During your fall marketing campaigns, remember that it’s not always about attracting new audience members—it’s also about retaining your current ones. If treated correctly, your current patrons can be the best marketing asset in your arsenal.

That said, ensure you either start or improve your loyalty programs to thank the patrons who come back show after show, year after year. Ideas for membership loyalty bonuses include:

  • Priority seating options
  • Free size upgrades or refills at concession stands
  • A personalized gift or discount on birthdays 
  • Waived online ticket purchasing fees
  • Special members-only events

Offer Promotions and Add-Ons

Cultivating a loyal patron base may start with a few freebies or discounts. That said, ensure the promotions during your fall season are enticing enough to engage new audience members. 

When launching a new and exciting promotion, communicate it across all channels to reach as many people as possible. When considering the promotions you want to enact, decide what types of patrons you want to buy your tickets—direct promos toward important sections of your target market or your general community. Discounts for groups like students, seniors, healthcare professionals, or military personnel are never a bad place to start. 

Additionally, add-ons play an important role in bolstering overall production profits and your organization’s brand reputation. When new and existing patrons buy tickets, make sure you present bundle deals (with merch, concessions, or season tickets) to increase your average order value. 

Host Community Events & Sponsor Others

Not all your marketing should be done online. Instead, welcome new and existing patrons into your space for events of all kinds. These can range from fundraisers to workshops, summer stock productions, or simple social mixers. 

Along the same lines, consider sponsoring local causes, donating a percentage of your proceeds to a nonprofit, or volunteering with your cast and crew at a nonprofit of your choice. Not only are you making a real difference in the world, but you’re also increasing your theatre’s recognition in the community and building a strong, reliable image.

On The Stage’s Marketing Tools

If you find yourself in the trenches of fall season marketing, know you’re not alone. On The Stage (OTS) offers a comprehensive marketing suite that can:

  • Grow awareness of your program through social platform integrations, email marketing, targeted marketing campaigns, and show art
  • Increase conversion rates and sell more tickets through Broadway-style show sites or a customizable ticketing widget embedded on your website
  • Nurture and grow your patron base with ticket buyer outreach, patron relationship management, engagement tools, reports, and insights
  • Increase efficiency and effectiveness by seamlessly integrating OTS with social platforms and marketing automation tools

If you’re ready to elevate the theatre experience for all, book a personalized demo with On The Stage today. 

Related products and solutions